excellent

very good, very interesting and packed with facts
great performance. unusual story but the fact it's true is amazing

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Another hit from Harris

Excellent story and narration. This true story has a more intricate plot than some of his fictional books!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An excellent audiobook from the BBC

Written by Robert Harris & read by the Scottish actor David Rintoul. This is an excellent audiobook of one the most infamous hoaxes of modern history. What will become apparent is men & it really is a drama about men (women are conspicuous by their absence) who ought to have known better. The main characters are motivated by the baser instincts of rapaciousness & egoism. Any attempt at human decency is undermined by complacency, ineptitude & sheer stupidity. A well researched account which results in an unattractive portrayal of the dramatis personae. However a fantastic listen!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Riveting!

I was aware of the Hitler Diaries fiasco in the early 1980s but only to the extent that I vaguely knew someone had got egg on their face but wasn’t sure who or why. Never could I have imagined how many people, who should have known very much better, found themselves coated from head to foot in a chicken run’s worth of egg - and for no good reason other than greed, hubris, fantasising and downright carelessness!
You kind of know it’s going to be funny when the forger, having discovered an aptitude for falsifying, gets booked by the police for forging .... 27 Deutschmarks worth of luncheon vouchers. Undeterred our man hones his skills and starts churning out Hitler ‘art work’ and ‘poetry’. His audacity is matched only by the gullibility of his buyers. After several twists and turns he meets a Stern journalist suffering from the lethal combination of being perennially in debt, unable to convert his journalistic research into readable prose and therefore missing out on the career trajectory he thinks he deserves, and neo nazism. He’s already virtually bankrupted himself by buying Goring’s dilapidated old yacht but lives for the day he can touch or own something penned by the Fuhrer. Diaries churned out to order by the forger from Stuttgart answer all his prayers: his employer, the downmarket mag Stern shells out DM 9 million for the purchase, and he lifts a hefty “commission” for himself before handing over the cash to the forger. Well before publication date the hack is living in a posh apartment with a separate suite for Hitler and other 3rd Reich memorabilia, showering champagne all over the place and refusing to do any other work.
Management egg him on and eventually start trying to syndicate the diaries to the likes of Rupert Murdoch and Newsweek. More twists and turns and in the end, inevitably, the whole edifice of fantasy and falsehood comes crashing down. To a man they all make a vital mistake, namely never getting the documents properly verified and each bunch of people wherever they are in the hierarchy taking the word of the last one down. When eventually the magazine does permit some attempts at authentication, they somehow manage to submit an already forged Hitler signature against which to compare the newly forged ones. By this time even our very own eminence Hugh Trevor-Roper has pronounced them genuine and shared in the egg.
Robert Harris turns some meticulous research into a rip-roaring yarn with some real laugh-out-loud moments. E.g. the forger using post war paper over which he throws tea, binding it with a synthetic cord and stamping Hitler’s initials with a letraset type device on the front - only, he gets one of the initials wrong. Do any of the publisher’s Board members notice this? The heck they do! At one point Stern’s newly appointed Finance Director is ordered to find hundreds of thousands of D-Marks NOW - when all the banks are shut. He gets a taxi to the airport where Deutsche Bank has a branch open, stuffs a bag full which the journalist then carries off into the night on a flight to Stuttgart. When the golden eggs represented by the diaries start running out because they’ve reached 1945, the forger mysteriously finds some nudes, a third version of Mein Kampf and an opera penned by the Fuhrer. Does anyone stop to wonder how a man who was notoriously lazy, constantly laid up with some hypochondriac ailment and supposedly running an empire and waging wars found time for all this artistic output? No, they saw only dollar signs.
Under the laughs and sheer crazy incredibility of this tale runs the rather sinister thread of how much Nazi memorabilia still seems to have a market, all over the world, with aficionados gazing at their acquisitions wistfully in purpose-built vaults in their luxurious mansions, while people who should have been long dead or incarcerated keep popping up in the narrative, living comfortably in Switzerland, Spain and Argentina.
But a VERY good, gripping read!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A thriller about greed, credulity and the fascination with the Third Reich

A thriller as well written as Robert Harris’s later fictional works, this is a captivating story about an infamous event. Brilliantly read, this is a superb non-fiction audio book

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An excellent overview of an intriguing story.

David Rintoul brings the words to life a masterpiece of story narration, Robert Harris takes the listener through a complicated and compelling journey gathering the myriad strands of intrigue and events that demonstrate the human frailty of money, greed and avarice, an excellent storyline delivered simply.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

13 people found this helpful

Truth Stranger Than Fiction

Excellent exposition on greed, vanity, stupidity, self deception and other ugly & ridiculous mysteries of human nature.

The narrator, too is also very good.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A fascinating listen

Retrospectively it’s unimaginable that so little due diligence would take place and people would want to be so easily fooled. A great listen

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Another good story

I have enjoyed reading Robert Harris for more years than I care to admit to! Now that I can listen to them in the car, as a bedtime story etc I enjoy them even more. Although I thoroughly enjoyed this story I did feel at times that it was being dragged out. Short story long if you know what I mean, but I certainly do not regret buying it and I listened right to the end.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Unexpectedly engrossing

I possibly hadn’t read the blurb fully and so was not expecting a non-fiction account of the Hitler diaries fiasco. However the incompetence, ill-timing, bad judgements and naivety of the protagonists make for a totally compelling story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!