Curate's Egg

Brilliant one liners,great dialogue,excellent vocal performance.
Convoluted plot ,which was hard to follow at times....a bit like Raymond Chandler☺

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Down these mean streets…

Philip Marlowe, the honest private eye in a dishonest world, is back in this continuation novel - the first time a female writer has taken on the challenge, and it’s a daunting one. John Banville, writing as Benjamin Black, pulled it off with The Black-Eyed Blonde, perhaps the best of the post-Chandler Marlowe adventures. The bar is high - but Mina’s noir yarn doesn’t disappoint. The Second Murderer is well-constructed and paced, and Mina approximates Chandler’s style in her brilliant descriptive writing about Los Angeles. Some of the similes work better than others. The plotting is just as dense and elaborate as Chandler’s own. But it all ties up neatly - and the closing scenes are beautifully done. Chandler continues to fascinate because his novels focused mainly on character and style. Plot often seemed secondary. Chandler’s The Long Goodbye was an attempt at exploring Marlowe the man, and his loneliness, within the parameters of detective fiction, and it succeeded in expanding them. The difficulty for those taking up the baton now is that they will inevitably tend to focus more on plot - maybe there’s a limit in a continuation novel to what you can do with such an iconic character - and there’s always the risk of lapsing into pastiche, or not quite nailing the original style/voice. That makes it even more gratifying when someone pulls it off, avoiding the pitfalls, as Mina largely does. It’s a relatively short novel. The narration is well done if arguably a little OTT, but it worked for me - and I hope Mina returns to the seedy backstreets of Marlowe’s L.A. soon.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A pretty decent story

The story is a bit unclear at times (some may say that is similar to Raymond chandler!)

The narration worked really well for me.

I enjoyed this book. Ok, it’s not a classic but it is worth a listen

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great nostalgic crime novel

I thoroughly enjoyed this nostalgic modern take on Philip Marlow's adventures.
The narration was a typical voice of the 1930s and 40s which made this audio really enjoyable, although these the end of the Novell's sure I heard a phrase referring to 'JETLAG' which didn't come in until the late 50s onwards (funny thing, I've never suffered from it on trips the the US)

I've looked for other books by Me Mine and I hope they are as good as this one.
A very good listen, especially the narrator, he got that Philip Marlow twang off just great.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Passable

Far from the worst of the new Marlowe novels but also far from the best. The story is rather underwhelming but the first person Marlowe narration is a fair approximation of the original.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Disappointing on so many levels.

This is the fourth Marlow novel ‘written in the style of Raymond Chandler’ that I have read. Previous encounters being: Only to Sleep by Lawrence Osborne read by Ray Porter, The Goodbye Coast by Joe Ide read by Vikas Adam and The Black Eyed Blonde by John Banville read by Denis Boutsikaris, the only one so far that could be said to convincingly approach the voice of Raymond Chandler.

The Second Murderer, however, never convinced for one moment, quite possible the writer was trying too hard. I felt no sense of authenticity in the writing, key notes missed almost every time, at no point did I feel I was involved in anything even remotely resembling a Marlow novel. None of this helped by Scott Brick’s breathless, over the top reading, driving the whole enterprise into pastiche.

One to miss.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!