3rd in Isobel Dalhousie series

I loved this book. I wonder so much about Alexander McCall-Smith, the author. He was a classicist like me. Then he went into the law. Then he taught. He plays in the Really Useless Orchestra in Edinburgh and he clearly knows some Italian and loves Italy. I have had a similar life so I really identify with his thoughts, ideas and interests. I met a Scots lady who knows him lately and we get on well. She also played in the same orchestra. We do not share my passion for duplicate Bridge or my faith in God. Isobel I think must be an atheist. I wonder how the author has got into the mind of a curious woman philosopher so well, including her thoughts about men.
I long for more audible books in this series and in the 44 Scotland Street series. It hurts my eyes to read these days. So I listen instead. I love the gentle Scottish accent of the reader. She is so much better than Radio 4's "Book at Bedtime." Thank you both for giving me so much pleasure.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

Don't bother

Boring. Pretentious. Narrator's voice irritating. Pity, as I have enjoyed other work by this author.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Friend Lovers Chocolate

Excellent keeps you in suspense with a smile and wonder I love AMcSmith books x

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not the best reader

This lady reader is competent enough.
So - why a two star score for performance? Simple. I didn't like her, with that quasi-Embru accent but with bent English vowels finding their way into her speech. This is very Scottish book by a Scottish author, set entirely in lowland Scotland, in the country's capital. That deserves a Scots actress/reader. This reader isn't that, and from time to time she throws out reminders that grate on my 100% Scotsman's ears.
Then there's the book. I've read a great many of this author's books, particularly the Scotland Street set and the Mma Ramotswe books set in Botswana.
These Dalhousie books are - different. The voices are harsh, too harsh to my mind.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

No Plot

I kept waiting for a plot to materialise. Half way through the book I realised that wasn't going to happen. The premise of the book is essentially this: a pleasant lady observes other people. That's pretty much it. It's quite a calming book, without any excitement, nice enough to listen to but not compelling. It's just a description of the main character meeting various people, talking to them, and having feelings about it. The narrator does a good job.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Good book

I really enjoyed this book Davina Porter has such a lovely voice and the story was unusual and very entertaining

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Good but not best story

I got cross with main character Isabel In this story her getting involved seemed more like interfering this time. But having said I still wanted to know how it all worked out and leaves me wanting to listen to next book to find out more about the characters.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Sadly, it's a very monotonous read.

I have read a lot of Alexander McCall Smiths books and enjoyed them, but this one was one really boring narrative. It seemed to be a rambling of the various characters' thoughts that could have been interesting or fun but weren't. The story (if there was one) was of a heart transplant. The outcome of which was the authors view set out via Isabel - of what that donor feels after transplant! There is no happy finality for Isobel. (She continues in her un-requited love.)The only finality is the authors view of the outcome of a heart transplant.

The narrator is extremely unprofessional in that throughout the reading, constant noises (that should have been avoided) could be heard in the background. I am sorry to say I definitely would not recommend taking your time to read this book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!