Wish I'd bought the book...

Not as imaginative as AT's previous books, this seems a little vanilla. What really let's it down is the narration. There's no menace or peril, some of the characters sound like 14 year old children. I'll read the next one.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

wonderfully funny, imaginative & horrific

I'd previously only read Children of Time from Tchaikovsky, a novel which is endlessly imaginative if a little... cold. The relative lack of humanity in the story was born out in the text, which lacked much in the way of humour or levity. However, it made up for it with sensational world-building, speculative evolution spinning off into such bizarre but credible pathways.

His Final Architecture series is, so far (I've listened to the first 2 books) quite different. The detailed, complex and slightly inscrutable setting is certainly still present, though with as much focus on technological advancement as biological evolution this time.

The characters, meanwhile, are far more relatable than in Children of Time. They are flawed, brave, cowardly, and determined in turn, with a strong core of idiosyncrasies running throughout each of them. Most of all, though, they are just damned FUNNY, despite not all of them even being human.

Special commendations to Olly and Trine, in particular. Olly is so beautifully profane in her speech, which is set off perfectly by the sardonic Yorkshire-esque twang that Sophie Aldred gives her. The level of mortal offence she takes at the presence, the mere existence, of others is a delight. She is the grumpiest arsehole with a heart of gold that I have come across in a while.

Then we have Trine, a character so utterly alien, yet man-made. The Hivers are basically sentient colonies of insects. Trine has refused to return his constituent parts back to the central depository for so long that they (accurate pronoun) have developed ego and eccentricities in equal measures.

I never get bored of these characters. The only one who annoys me a little is Idris, who is ostensibly the central character of this space opera. However, he makes up for his meek timidness by refusing to back down, insisting a course of action is necessary until it happens. Besides being a human McGuffin, always being kidnapped and passed from pillar to post against his own desires, he slowly develops into someone determined to do the right thing no matter the cost, so by the end of book 2 you are stood up rooting for him!

I have loved this series, and cannot wait from the next installment at the end of April 2023.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Perfect start to a trilogy

A great story by an author in their prime made excellent by the best narrator I've heard in a long time.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Tchaikovsky can do no wrong

A brilliant tale, well told.

I shall be demolishing this series in days at this rate!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The choice of reader is a shame.

Fascinating storyline. The reader leaves a lot to be desired. A very samey voice, whatever the action.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Fascinating tale with memorable characters

I really loved AT's Children series so picked Shards of Earth up when I saw it on sale. so glad I did. The story AT has come up with is great, and equally as complex and riveting as the Children series. I have loved the characters. Ollie Teemu is now one of my favourite characters from any series. Looking forward to part two.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

my god the narration

can't say if it's on par with the rest of his work, narrator is absolutely terrible.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Amazing!!! So much world building

Great characters and detail, with pacing to match.
Narration is excellent.
I cannot wait until the 2nd book drops in a few months.
Might just be the best book I have read.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A bit of a trudge

I do like this author, but for me this was a trudge. I normally get engrossed in a story, but I felt I had to keep going back to try and figure out what was going on! I just couldn't build the picture in my head, which is a first for me.

I kept trying to like this story but gave up 50% the way through. The characters are fun and likeable.

Performance by Sophie was great. I was really looking forward to this, but was left, well... meh...

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Trying a bit too hard for my liking.

The story line is promising. However I felt that the feminism was ludicrously contrived and the character development was problematic. I can understand why some listeners would want to give up early. I did, but decided to stick with it. I can't say I was rewarded richly.
Sophie Alfred delivers a very good performance that lifted the story enough to make this book worthwhile.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!